Bharat Bandh on July 9
UPSC Analysis by Suryavanshi IAS
Understanding the Legal, Constitutional, and Socioeconomic Dimensions of the Nationwide Strike
“Strikes are the language of the unheard.” — Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.
In India, Bharat Bandh is not just a shutdown; it's a reflection of democratic assertion. The upcoming Bharat Bandh on July 9, 2025, is a powerful moment for UPSC aspirants to study labour unrest, constitutional rights, and governance challenges from a multi-dimensional perspective.
🔍 Why Is the Bharat Bandh Happening?
Over 25 crore workers from critical public sectors—banking, postal, mining, transport, and more—will go on strike. This call is led by a coalition of 10 central trade unions and supported by farmer and rural worker organisations. Their core grievance: the "anti-worker, anti-farmer, and pro-corporate" tilt in government policies.
⚖️ Legal and Constitutional Angle
🧾 Right to Strike – Is it Fundamental?
-
Article 19(1)(c): Grants the right to form associations or unions.
-
However, right to strike is not a fundamental right.
-
The Supreme Court (B.R. Singh v. Union of India, 1990) ruled that strike is not a fundamental right but a legal one governed by statutes.
-
The Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 allows strike under prescribed conditions.
-
➡️ Thus, the legality of this bandh depends on whether due notice and procedural requirements have been followed.
📜 Public Order vs. Protest
-
Under Article 19(1)(a & b), the right to free speech and peaceful protest exists.
-
But reasonable restrictions under Article 19(2) & 19(3) apply in the interest of public order, security, and morality.
-
State governments may impose Section 144 or use Essential Services Maintenance Act (ESMA) to prevent disruption.
⚠️ Ethical dilemma for aspirants: How should the state balance the right to dissent with ensuring essential public services?
🏗️ Labour Reforms: The Trigger Point
The primary opposition is against the four new labour codes, namely:
-
Code on Wages, 2019
-
Industrial Relations Code, 2020
-
Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code, 2020
-
Social Security Code, 2020
🚨 Key Issues Raised by Unions:
-
Dilution of collective bargaining power.
-
Tougher conditions for strikes and union formation.
-
Increased contractualisation of labour.
-
Reduction in job security, especially in small establishments.
-
Weakening of inspection mechanisms.
From the UPSC lens, aspirants must analyze:
-
📌 Labour as a Concurrent subject – Central vs. State dynamics.
-
📌 The ILO Conventions on labour rights India has ratified.
-
📌 Link with Ease of Doing Business index and informal sector realities.
💰 Socioeconomic Impact: A Deep Dive
🧑🏭 Employment Crisis
-
India's unemployment rate hovers around 7-8%, with youth unemployment crossing 20%.
-
The protest also highlights “Jobless Growth”, where GDP grows but job creation stagnates.
🌾 Rural-Urban Disparities
-
Demands to expand MGNREGA to urban areas reflect urban distress.
-
In rural India, rising inflation, stagnant incomes, and agrarian distress fuel discontent.
🏥 Public Services Under Pressure
-
Protesters demand:
-
Increased spending on healthcare, education.
-
Filling of vacant government posts.
-
Reversal of the trend of hiring retirees and contractual workers.
-
💡 UPSC aspirants should link this with SDG Goal 8: Decent work and economic growth.
🛑 Impact on Daily Life: What Will Be Affected
| Affected | Unaffected |
|---|---|
| Banking services | Schools and Colleges |
| Postal operations | Private offices |
| Public transport (state-run) | Trains (partial disruptions) |
| Coal mining and industries | Emergency services |
| Government offices | Courts (varies by region) |
🧠 UPSC Mains Relevance
✅ GS Paper II – Polity & Governance
-
Rights vs. Restrictions
-
Role of Trade Unions
-
Public protests and democratic accountability
✅ GS Paper III – Economy
-
Labour market reforms
-
Informal sector vulnerabilities
-
Public service delivery challenges
✅ Essay / Ethics
-
Dignity of Labour
-
State vs. Citizen: Ethics of governance
-
Democratic protests: Moral or disruptive?
🔎 Suryavanshi IAS Thought Capsule: For the UPSC Thinker
"Reforms are vital, but without social dialogue, they breed resistance. A democracy must reform with its people, not against them."
As future administrators, UPSC aspirants must not only understand the legalities and policy background, but also develop a sensitive, inclusive, and balanced perspective. This Bharat Bandh is not just a strike—it’s a case study on governance, citizen-state relations, and the evolving idea of economic justice in 21st-century India.
📘 Practice Question (GS II – 15 Marks)
Discuss the constitutional and legal validity of public sector strikes in India. Examine how labour reforms have impacted the rights and welfare of workers in recent years.
📗 Practice Question (GS III – 10 Marks)
Evaluate the implications of the four labour codes on India’s informal workforce and economic growth.
For further UPSC-ready analysis, follow Suryavanshi IAS – Where Insight Meets Preparation.
No comments:
Post a Comment