Difference Between Act and Law

 

⚖️ Difference Between Act and Law: A Legal Fundamentals Primer for UPSC

🖋️ By: Suryavanshi IAS, Lucknow

---

Introduction

In UPSC exams and legal studies, aspirants often come across the terms "Law" and "Act". While many use these interchangeably, they are not the same. Understanding the difference between an Act and a Law is fundamental in Indian polity and constitution topics, especially for Prelims, Mains GS-II, and Essay.

---

Basic Definitions

Term	Meaning
Law	A system of rules enforced by an authority to regulate human behaviour and maintain order in society.
Act	A specific piece of legislation passed by the Parliament or State Legislature that becomes enforceable once it is signed by the President or Governor.

Comparison Chart: Act vs Law

Basis of Comparison	Act	Law
Meaning	A statute passed by the legislature concerning a specific subject.	A system of rules governing the behaviour of people in a society.
Nature	Specific	Generic
What is it?	A bill that has received legislative and presidential assent.	An established set of enforceable principles.
Function	Explains why and how a specific law is enforced.	States what is right/wrong and prescribes duties.
Scope	Limited to a particular subject (e.g., Contract Act).	Encompasses all rules enforceable by the state.
Examples	The Right to Education Act, 2009; Income Tax Act, 1961	Criminal Law, Civil Law, Constitutional Law
Objective	To inform about rules for specific cases.	To ensure justice, public order, and equality.

Understanding Through Examples

• Right to Education Act, 2009 is a specific Act.

• It is based on the fundamental right to education, a concept under law (specifically, Article 21A of the Constitution).

• All Acts are part of the broader system called law, but not all laws are Acts (e.g., common law, judicial precedents).

How an Act Becomes Law (Enactment Process)

1. Bill Introduced in either house of Parliament.

2. Debated & Voted in both Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha.

3. Presidential Assent is taken.

4. Becomes an Act and is published in the Gazette of India.

5. Enforceability begins from a notified date.

This Act now forms part of the Indian legal system (law).

---

Why This is Important for UPSC?

This topic appears in:

• GS Paper II: Indian Constitution, Parliament, Legislative Process

• GS Paper IV: Ethics (rule of law, equality before law)

• Essay Paper: Themes like Rule of Law, Governance, Justice

• Interview: Application-based legal questions

---

UPSC Previous Year Questions (PYQs)

✅ Prelims

• 2019: With reference to the Parliament of India, consider the following statements:

  1. A private member’s bill can be introduced and passed.

  2. The President can withhold assent to any bill passed by Parliament.
     (Relevance: Law-making process and powers of legislature)

• 2013: Which of the following is/are the function/functions of the Cabinet Secretariat?
  (Indirect relevance: Legislative business coordination)

---

✅ Mains

• GS II (2020): “Parliament's power to amend the Constitution is limited.” In this light, discuss the theory of basic structure and its impact on legislative powers.

• GS II (2016): Examine the scope of Fundamental Rights in the light of the latest Supreme Court judgments on Right to Privacy.

---

🧠 Practice Questions for UPSC Aspirants

✍️ Mains Practice (GS II)

1. Distinguish between Law and Act. Explain their relevance in the Indian legislative system with suitable examples.

2. Discuss the legislative process in India. How does a Bill become an Act, and what role does the President play in it?

3. How does the enactment of specific Acts strengthen the implementation of fundamental rights in India? Explain with examples.

---

✅ Prelims MCQs

1. Which of the following statements is/are correct?

   1. All Acts are laws, but not all laws are Acts.

   2. An Act becomes law only after it receives Presidential assent.

   3. Laws can be based on customs and judicial decisions.

   Options:
   A. 1 and 2 only
   B. 2 and 3 only
   C. 1 and 3 only
   D. 1, 2 and 3
   ✅ Answer: D

2. Consider the following pairs:

   Act	Subject Area
   Income Tax Act, 1961	Finance
   Environment Protection Act, 1986	Environment
   Information Technology Act, 2000	Education

   
   

   A. Only 3
   B. Only 2
   C. 1 and 3
   D. All are correctly matched
   ✅ Answer: A

3. Which pair is incorrectly matched?

---

Conclusion

In simple words:
👉 Laws are the big umbrella of enforceable rules
👉 Acts are individual laws passed by Parliament under that umbrella.

As UPSC aspirants, understanding this distinction helps in interpreting legislative processes, governance mechanisms, and the functioning of the state, essential for both Prelims and Mains.

---

📚 For more such conceptual clarity, join our Polity Foundation Batch
📍 Suryavanshi IAS, Rahul Vihar, Lucknow
📞 Contact: 6306446114