Doctor’s Day and the Crisis of Modern Medicine: A Silent Erosion of Trust
By Suryavanshi IAS | For UPSC Aspirants – GS II, GS IV, Essay
Why This Topic Matters for Civil Services
Every July 1,
India observes National Doctor’s Day
to honour Dr. Bidhan Chandra Roy —
physician, freedom fighter, and chief minister. Yet, this solemn tribute often
goes unnoticed, lost in the noise of major policy rollouts like GST (2017) or Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (2024).
This oversight is not incidental. It mirrors a deeper malaise — the slow, quiet erosion of the moral prestige and public trust in doctors, once revered as guardians of life.
I. Understanding the Transformation: A Timeline of Trust
A. The Past: From Priests to
Physicians
·
In pre-modern
society, healers were more spiritual
figures than scientists. Their legitimacy came from ritual purity and religious status, not
evidence-based skills.
·
The Industrial
Revolution changed everything. With germ theory, anaesthesia, and antibiotics, the doctor
became a miracle worker —
science-backed, state-supported, and socially respected.
Surgeons, once barbers, became bearers of the
scalpel and scientific certainty.
B. The Golden Age: The Doctor as Demigod
·
Post-Independence
India idolised the doctor. They were central to rural health missions, polio eradication, and family planning.
· The doctor-patient relationship was paternalistic but trusted: "Doctor sahib knows best."
II. The Present: From Reverence to Reluctance
The Epidemiological Transition (Omran, 1971)
·
As societies modernise, they shift:
o From
infectious diseases → to chronic non-communicable diseases (NCDs)
o From
high death rates → to long lifespans with degenerative conditions
·
India is now in Stage IV–V:
Dengue persists | Diabetes explodes | Mental
health emerges
A dual burden, with no easy cure.
Decline in Trust: 5 Realities
1.
Medicine became
uncertain:
Most modern treatments offer probabilities,
not guarantees.
“Reduce salt. Walk more.” These are not the miracle cures people expect.
2.
Healthcare became
expensive:
Out-of-pocket expenditure in India is among the highest globally.
Doctors are seen as agents of corporate
hospitals, not public servants.
3.
Advice became
unpopular:
In an age of consumerism, prescriptions
that demand restraint are resented.
4.
Commercialisation
eroded nobility:
Pharma, diagnostics, insurance — profit-driven industries now control healing.
5.
Public
frustration has new targets:
Doctors are the face of a system people can’t afford or trust.
They face violence, legal threats, and social suspicion.
III. The Future: What Lies Ahead for the Medical
Profession
A
Changing Doctor’s Role
·
From
Healer → Risk Communicator
·
From
Saviour → Lifestyle Coach
·
From Lone
Expert → Team Player (AI, Tech, Multi-Specialist Care)
Rise
of AI & Precision Medicine
·
AI can help doctors diagnose better, but empathy and ethical judgment will remain
human domains.
·
The future doctor must be as emotionally intelligent as scientifically
competent.
Trust
Must Be Rebuilt — Not Demanded
·
Tomorrow’s doctor must listen more, lecture less.
· The system must ensure affordability, accessibility, and accountability — else, no trust can survive.
IV. Solutions for Policy and Society
|
Domain |
Suggested
Reforms |
|
Medical Education |
Introduce ethics, empathy, and communication skills from
Year 1 of MBBS |
|
Healthcare Delivery |
Strengthen public health system (more AIIMS, CHCs, PHCs);
reduce private sector overreach |
|
Legal Safeguards |
Enforce laws against assault on doctors; introduce mediation in malpractice cases |
|
Doctor–Patient Relations |
Make informed consent, not blind trust, the basis of
medical engagement |
|
Public Campaigns |
Revive trust through “Jan Swasthya Abhiyan” —
public outreach by real doctors, not influencers |
V. UPSC Mains Relevance
GS Paper II:
·
Health sector policies
·
Government vs. market in public service delivery
·
Doctor–citizen trust gap
GS Paper IV (Ethics):
·
Role of public servants (doctors as health
providers)
·
Conflict of interest and moral courage
Essay:
·
“The doctor no longer wears a white coat — but
carries a heavy burden.”
· “Healing in the age of hashtags: Why trust is the real medicine.”
Model Mains Question (GS II)
Q. Discuss the changing role of doctors in India’s public health system in the context of the epidemiological and demographic transition. Suggest steps to restore trust between the medical community and the public.
Conclusion: The Moral Crisis of Modern Medicine
“Medicine
has not failed. Society’s expectations have changed faster than medicine can
deliver.”
Doctors are not faltering — they are caught in
the crossfire between old reverence and
new realities. They are expected to offer miracles in a world ruled by uncertainty, inequality, and algorithms.
As future policymakers, UPSC aspirants must
understand that healthcare is not just
science or infrastructure — it is a moral contract between the state,
society, and its healers.
Let us honour that contract not just on July
1, but every day — through good policy,
strong systems, and humane leadership.
“The doctor is not God. But the system must let
them be human again.”
— Suryavanshi IAS
No comments:
Post a Comment