India’s Procurement Puzzle: Lessons from Tamil Nadu’s Paddy Controversy

A UPSC-Focused Analysis for Prelims & Mains 2026

📝 Context

The recent crisis in Tamil Nadu’s paddy procurement during the kuruvai season has reopened debates on the sustainability, efficiency, and future direction of India’s foodgrain procurement system.

The Tamil Nadu Civil Supplies Corporation (TNCSC), procuring on behalf of the Food Corporation of India (FCI), faced:

Time overruns
Corruption allegations
Surplus arrivals due to expansion of paddy acreage (by ~2 lakh acres)

This issue is not limited to Tamil Nadu but reflects a national challenge in rice procurement, storage, crop choices, subsidy burden, and import dependence on pulses and oilseeds.

📊 Procurement & Stock Data: What Is the Problem?

1. All-India Rice Procurement: Steep Surge

119.86 lakh tonnes (as of Oct 31, 2025)
vs
82.08 lakh tonnes (Oct 31, 2024)

2. Rice Stocks in the Central Pool: Excessive & Unsustainable

356.1 lakh tonnes (Oct 2025)
Norm: 102.5 lakh tonnes

India has 3.5× the required rice stock, reflecting over-procurement and low offtake relative to storage norms.

3. Wheat vs Rice Utilisation

Wheat PDS offtake sometimes exceeded procurement (2022–24).
Rice: annual procurement 525–547 lakh tonnes,
PDS offtake only 392–427 lakh tonnes → chronic surplus.

4. Rising Food Subsidy Burden

₹2 lakh crore annually spent on food subsidy.

🇮🇳 The Irony: Surplus Rice, But Import-Dependent for Pulses & Edible Oils

Pulses

India is the world’s largest producer (252.4 lakh tonnes, 2024–25)
But imports cost ₹30,000 crore
Procurement at MSP has declined in the last two years.

Edible Oils

Import bill: ₹1.2 lakh crore (2023–24)
Import dependence: 55%
Production stagnating despite ~25 million hectares under oilseeds
Russia–Ukraine war raised global prices sharply.

Policy paradox: India is over-secure in rice and wheat but under-secure in pulses and oils — commodities essential to nutrition.

⚠️ Core Concerns Highlighted by the Situation

1. Unsustainable Procurement of Rice

Excess stocks = high storage cost + wastage + inefficiency
MSP and assured procurement incentivize farmers to grow more paddy

2. Crop Rotation Being Undermined

Continuous paddy cultivation impacts:
- Soil health
- Water table
- Biodiversity

3. Import Dependence for Pulses & Oilseeds

A national nutrition risk
Significant forex outflow
Historical policy errors (cheap edible oil imports in 1990s) still haunting farmers

4. Structural Weakness in PDS

ICRIER: 28% leakage of rice and wheat (2023)
Over-procurement does not translate into improved nutrition outcomes

🌱 Need for Crop Diversification: The Most Important Reform

Why farmers stick to paddy?

Guaranteed MSP
Assured procurement
Less price risk
Poor market support for pulses & oilseeds

Way Forward

Area-specific crop diversification based on demand-supply studies
Financial support during transition (direct income support + crop insurance)
Assured procurement of pulses & oilseeds like paddy
Export freedom for rice to prevent build-up of stocks
Soil health campaigns to discourage monoculture practices

👥 Role of FPOs, SHGs & Cooperatives: Building Agriculture Institutions

Why FPOs matter?

Reduce middlemen
Enable direct linkage with buyers
Assist in cluster-based crop planning
Provide soil and market data
Enhance bargaining power

Applications:

Direct tie-ups: e.g., papad manufacturers with blackgram farmers
Participating in procurement: e.g., West Bengal uses FPOs for paddy procurement
Extension services: soil health, diversification guidance
Supply chain building

But FPOs are still nascent—need capacity-building and government facilitation.

🚚 Reforming Procurement, Storage & Distribution

Key Questions India Must Address:

1. Should procurement remain centrally dominated (FCI, NAFED)?

Can decentralisation improve efficiency?

2. Is MSP + assured procurement model sustainable for rice?

Surplus production vs storage burden vs groundwater stress

3. Can India shift to “demand-based procurement”?

States procure only what is needed for PDS
Remaining resources redirected to pulses/oilseeds

4. Should India reconsider import policies for edible oils?

Protect local farmers?
Promote domestic oilseed production?

5. How to address leakage in PDS?

End-to-end digitisation
GPS tagging of grain movement
Aadhaar-enabled PDS
Social audit of PDS
Strengthen vigilance & transparency

🧭 UPSC Mains Relevance

GS3 – Agriculture:

MSP
Procurement
PDS reform
Crop diversification
Pulses & oilseed production
Import dependence
Food security vs nutrition security
Storage & FCI reforms

GS2 – Governance:

Leakages
Centre–State coordination
Implementation gaps
Cooperative federalism in agriculture

Possible UPSC Mains Questions:

Q1. “India’s foodgrain procurement policy has ensured food security but created structural distortions in agriculture.” Discuss.

Q2. Examine the reasons for India’s continued import dependence on pulses and edible oils despite being a leading agricultural economy.

Q3. Discuss the role of Farmers Producers’ Organisations (FPOs) in reforming India’s agricultural value chains.

🔍 UPSC Prelims Pointers

Important data:

Rice stock: 356.1 lakh tonnes vs norm 102.5 lakh tonnes
Edible oil import: ₹1.2 lakh crore
Pulses import: ₹30,000 crore
Food subsidy: ₹2 lakh crore annually
Pulses production: 252.4 lakh tonnes (2024–25)
Paddy procurement rise: 82 lakh tonnes → 119.86 lakh tonnes (YoY)

Concepts:

MSP
Central Pool Stocks
FCI
PDS
NFSA
Crop diversification
Soil health
Import substitution

🟢 Conclusion

India’s agricultural challenge is not just about producing more food, but about producing the right mix of crops sustainably.
The Tamil Nadu paddy procurement controversy is a reminder that:

Excessive reliance on rice and wheat
High food subsidies
Rising import bills for nutrition-critical crops
Weak PDS management

…are all symptoms of a system that urgently needs reform.

A balanced agricultural policy must prioritise diversification, institutional innovation (FPOs), demand-based procurement, and farmer confidence while ensuring long-term national food and nutrition security.

Blog Archive

Tuesday, November 18, 2025